Wow. I LOVE my book club because books that I probably wouldn't have ever read or gotten around to reading are on my radar, and most have shifted my perspective or life with impact. This month's selection (with what I'm sure will result in a heated debate tonight at our monthly meeting) was
Battle Hymn of the Tiger Mother
by Amy Chua. This is not a fun beach read, or story about family, or really a story at all. This is a microscopic view of a family from the autobiographical viewpoint of the matriarch of the Chua family. Chuas was raised Chinese, a second generation immigrant raising two Chinese-American daugthers with a Jewish-American husband. You feel and hear the screams of this mother as she desperately tries to do what's right and raise wonderful children that grow up to be responsible, successful, fulfilled, and happy adults. I know the big controversy about this book is that it challenges Western parenting, blah blah blah. For me, the most important part about this book is not the Chinese vs. Western way of parenting, it's just parenting period. As a teacher, I have seen so many spoiled, disrespectful, lazy, ungrateful and just plain poorly raised students pass through our hallways. But the ones with tough (i.e. good) parents are kind, respectful, motivated, hardworking, curious, interested in learning, genuine, and have a goodness about them. These are the straight A students, yes, but they also are interesting, thoughtful, and confident. Some may be shy because they don't like the high school cliches, gossip, and plain silliness, but often they have plenty of friends and when they do speak up in class, it's because they have something thoughtful and intelligent to say, not just because they want attention or to hear the sound of their own voice. It's funny because Chua could be overzealous and unrealistic and of course way too demanding, and that is what some people who read or hear about this book will only focus on. But in reality, Chua had some great concepts, values, and instincts, and ultimately, she knew that by being tough on her children and challenging them to be the best versions of themselves every step of the way, they would grow up to be happier and more successful adults. Yes, the kid who gets everything handed to them might like their parents as they are growing up (usually not even the case even when they get everything they want!), but realistically, many of these kids grow up resenting their parents for not instilling better morals, values, and goals in them. Look at
Death of a Salesman! Biff would have been a happier adult if Willy would have held him to higher standards (and of course, been a better example himself). Instead, he glorified Biff and as a result, high school was the best Biff's life ever got. Now, trust me, I loved high school as anyone that grew up with me will tell you. But, at the same time, my parents had high standards for me: they expected A's, excellence when playing sports, and respect (I still don't feel comfortable saying "that sucks" in front of my dad). Where they as tough on me as Chua is on her kids? No. But they did hold high standards that I feel instilled a work ethic, desire to succeed, and motivation in me. Parenting is tough and there is no guidebook, but Chua's book should be on bookshelves right next to
What to Expect When You're Expecting. Not because you should follow everything that Chua did with her kids, but you should at least being aware of the high standards that exist as these may cause you to raise yours. I once had a parent tell me that one of her friends said, "I just want to get my daughter through high school without getting pregnant." Her friend responded, "Why not set your standards a little higher?" I mean, really? How about encouraging her strengths so she is focused on those and a good future so teen pregnancy won't even be a possibility (well, I guess it's always a possibility, but you know what I mean). I know it's cliche, but I have always loved the quote, "Shoot for the moon; even if you fail, you'll be among the stars." Set our standards high for our children and students. Then if they fall a little short, they will still be successful, hardworking people. My old college teammate's blog has a similar message about standards and expectations that you might also enjoy:
http://foreveryoungward.blogspot.com/2011_03_01_archive.html